In his letter, he asked the IRS to remove Ensign Peak’s tax-exempt status and compel it … Reality is the church likely has sufficient technical reasons to pursue the path it has pursued. David Nielsen, himself a Mormon, worked at Ensign Peak Advisors, the investment division of the church, prior to filing the complaint. The Post reported that the letter, according to a copy provided by Lars Nielsen, said, “his employment had become unworkable after his wife and children left the Mormon church and asked him to follow them.". There is nothing in these allegations that indicates that LDS leadership is enriching itself. The 74-page document filed with the IRS and obtained by Religion Unplugged shows that Ensign Peak Advisors, Inc. saw owned assets under management grow to more than $100 billion from $10 billion in the past 22 years, fueled by a mix of investment strategy and tithe money from church members. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. Ensign, as an integrated auxiliary of a church, would not be taxed on investment income such as interest, dividends and capital gains. According to the whistleblower complaint, the LDS Church takes in about $7 Billion in tithing each year, spends $6 billion and invests the rest. He had an issue with something in my previous piece. The whistleblower complaint noted that David had concerns about some practices at EPA since 2013 and voiced some of those … I would think retroactivity would be really unlikely here. Whistleblower - Ensign Peak Advisors; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. I have expressed the view that there is probably nothing for the IRS to investigate. The whistleblower … The whistleblower, David Nielsen, is a Mormon who worked for the church until September, his brother, Lars Nielsen, told CNN. I mean, there may be moral/religious/ethical questions, but if it invested in-house, it would qualify under 501(c)(3) as an exempt org with a religious purpose. But the complaint alleges that Roger Clarke, the president of the church's investment division, Ensign Peak Advisors, said the funds would be used in the event of the second coming. Reilly - It seems like the commensurate thing would be based on a charity that was formed to raise and invest to support the religion in general and never spent anything. I could really nerd you out on how that question might be answered when the UBTI is being generated by partnerships, but the shortcut that Deloitte took of describing the trade or business as investing or investing in partnerships, rather than listing out the likely numerous businesses the partnerships were engaged in, was probably reasonable. Until September 2019, Nielsen had been a senior portfolio manager for the Mormon-church run investment non-profit, Ensign Peak Advisors. He notes that there are two bases for Ensign’s exemption. Really, the IRS does not have the resources to regulate the not-for-profit sector and it is not very good at it when it tries. As a support company and auxiliary to the church, Ensign Peak is allowed to make tax-exempt money in its work for the church provided the money is for religious, educational or other charitable purposes. He … According to the whistleblower complaint, the LDS Church takes in about $7 Billion in tithing each year, spends $6 billion and invests the rest. The complaint was filed by David Nielsen, a former portfolio manager for the church’s nonprofit investment arm Ensign Peak Advisors, with the help of his brother Lars Nielsen, who spoke with and provided supporting documents to The Post. But the law as it applies here seems ambiguous at best; to the extent Ensign Peak was on the wrong side of the line, I think it has a strong argument that it wasn’t deliberately there. But it also invested in partnerships which would generate unrelated business taxable income. According to the Washington Post, the whistleblower, David A. Nielsen, called on the IRS to strip the tax-exempt status from Ensign Peak Advisors, an organization affiliated with the church that houses its money and puts it into an investment portfolio to generate additional funds. The whistleblower allegation that Ensign Peak Advisors, has in its over 20 years of existence accumulated over $100 billion dollars in excess tithes and the investment returns thereon is generating some excitement. David’s LinkedIn profile shows that he worked at Ensign Peak Advisors Inc. in Salt Lake City between 2010 and 2019, where he was a senior portfolio manager. The complaint came from David Nielsen, a former employee of Ensign Peak who resigned earlier this year after his wife and children ended their church membership. This is also true of others who have consulted with Paul Glader, as I'm sure you saw in his coincident breaking story in Religion Unplugged. I asked Professor Brunson about that. A whistleblower complaint to the IRS accuses The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints of building a $100 billion investment portfolio using donations intended for charitable purposes, potentially in violation of federal tax laws, according to, Church spokesman Eric Hawkins declined to respond to The Post’s reporting, and instead directed The Salt Lake Tribune to, According to The Post, Nielsen’s complaint describes the church collecting roughly $7 billion in member contributions each year. I have been a CPA for over 30 years focusing on taxation. The complaint was filed by David A. Nielsen, a 41-year-old Mormon who worked until September as a senior portfolio manager at the church’s investment division, a company named Ensign Peak Advisors that is based near the church’s headquarters. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. Ensign is not a private foundation. I think about it ALL THE TIME.”. The Washington Post report is based upon a whistleblower complaint filed with the Internal Revenue Service by David Nielsen, 41, who until September worked for Ensign Peak Advisors, a company that manages the church’s investments. Is there any question about how much wealth the church could accumulate? A church-owned ‘anti-bank’ Consider what happened in … The whistleblower allegation that Ensign Peak Advisors, has in its over 20 years of existence accumulated over $100 billion dollars in excess … All rights reserved. As an integral part of the Mormon church, Ensign is required to operate exclusively for religious, educational, or other charitable purposes. Later reports indicated that Lars approached the Washington Post with the information, and that David was against releasing the information publicly. When it comes to churches, LDS may be sui generis in that regard. According to the National Whistleblower Center, IRS 211 claims — under which the accusations made against Ensign Peak Advisors fall — are signed under oath and penalty of perjury. And how much should the church be salting away for a rainy day? That money isn’t being spent on charitable endeavors, as required by law. It is just not that big a one. A former employee of the Church’s non-profit investment firm, Ensign Peak Advisors, has complained to the IRS. The Salt Lake Tribune, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) public charity and contributions are tax (Francisco Kjolseth | Tribune file photo) Visitors take in the sights at Temple Square in Salt Lake City on November 29, 2019. The Wall Street Journal on Saturday published a story on Ensign Peak Advisors, the investment arm of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The Mormon Church's investment division is a company named Ensign Peak Advisors. Either way, the janitorial objection I find most compelling is that, by shifting it from paid to volunteer, we’re taking away one manner that we could provide jobs for people who aren’t able to find jobs. The whistleblower in the case is David A. Nielsen, a former senior portfolio manager working with Ensign Peak Advisors. And there is nothing in the tax law that prevents churches from accumulating wealth.”. I think they do and still think so..... Now, Ensign will almost surely argue that it is an integral part of the church. Professor Hackney pointed me to Revenue Procedure 96-10 which indicates the sort of auxiliary organizations that share in the blessings of the church’s exemption from filing Form 990. According to a report in the Washington Post, David Nielsen, a senior portfolio manager at the Mormon church’s investment division, known as “Ensign Peak,” left Ensign and became a whistleblower. A inside whistle blower has alleged the Mormon Church misled members on how a $100 billion investment fund was used. If it is an “integrated auxiliary” though, it is a different story. I focus on the tax issues of individuals, businesses & more, Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, stands outside the historic Mormon Salt Lake Temple on December 17, 2019 in Salt Lake City, Utah. Brunson -  There’s always a chance, I suppose. Of that amount, the complaint alleges, $6 billion is spent on operating costs while the remaining $1 billion is transferred to Ensign Peak Advisors and added to the church’s investment portfolio. If you don’t have the patience for the whole video check out the last five minutes or so. In some sense I think what we are witnessing is the asking and answering of different questions. The complaint was made to the IRS on Nov. 21 by David A. Nielsen, a former senior portfolio manager for Ensign Peak Advisors, the church’s … Most financial scandals involving churches involve the people running them looting them, not the church saving up too much money. The whistleblower. Lars Nielsen, who provided the documents to reporters, said members deserve an apology from church leaders and the investment company. On the other hand, if I were involved in the preparation of that return and knew that the reason management did not give me the answer to the question was that management did not want the IRS to know what the total book value of its assets was, I would be pretty uncomfortable. Maybe if we knew what they were going to do with it there wouldn’t be such a surprise to members. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. Giuliani Promotes Anti-Semitic 'One World' Government Theory On Fox News. On the 17 th December, the Washington Post published an article about a former employee of Ensign Peak Advisors, (a not for profit corporation constituted under the direction of of the Corporation of the President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints). I consulted with a couple of people who should know and that seems to be the common view.”. A whistleblower alleges in the complaint, filed with the IRS, that billions of dollars collected in tithes mandatory donations by members were invested in an investment arm of the church Ensign Peak Advisors but in 22 years, has not been distributed to charitable causes in accordance with IRS rules, according to a report in the Washington Post. not being required to file Form 990). “Yes. The argument is that a private foundation is supposed to distribute 5% of its assets. Ensign has a problem there. That’s because there is not much of a case. My reading of the situation is that not much thought went into trade or business question. I have extensive experience with partnerships, real estate and high net worth individuals. YW pres, primary pres, bishop, but it's not true. It Was the Best-Kept Secret in the Investment World,” the Journal explored the remarkable growth of the investment fund. There is this “commensurate in scope” test to be concerned about for a “supporting organization”. (Photo by George Frey/Getty Images), EY & Citi On The Importance Of Resilience And Innovation, Impact 50: Investors Seeking Profit — And Pushing For Change, Michigan Economic Development Corporation With Forbes Insights, It’s Not Just The Taxes And Tariffs: Why Biden Should Reconsider The Trans-Pacific Partnership. Last month, Nielsen filed a complaint with the IRS in Ogden. David Nielsen did not speak to The Washington Post and has not commented publicly. Ask Larry: Will Changes In The Full Retirement Age Reduce My Social Security Benefit At 70? Nielsen was a senior portfolio manager and filed the complaint with his twin brother, Lars. But you should know how much you gave their (Ensign Peak Advisors) slush fund since the COP (Corporation of the President of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints) created it … One of the complaints that seems to come up a lot is that LDS does not have paid janitors. By Susie Madrak. I wrote: “I don’t think David Nielsen will be able to retire on the reward from this case. Its initial filing revealed The church has its own investment division, Ensign Peak Advisors, with offices close to the church’s headquarters in Salt Lake City. A whistleblower is accusing the Mormon church of allegedly violating federal tax laws and accumulating nearly $100 billion in charitable accounts. Of that amount, the complaint alleges, $6 billion is spent on operating costs while the remaining $1 billion is transferred to Ensign Peak Advisors and added to the church’s investment portfolio. Over 22 … Brunson -Right. Under the headline “The Mormon Church Amassed $100 Billion. (It is volunteer-driven, with only a couple levels of paid clergy, none of which are at the local congregation level.) A inside whistle blower has alleged the Mormon Church misled members on how a $100 billion investment fund was used. EPA is characterized as an integrated auxiliary of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. I thought when I reviewed the WB complaint it would be a nothing. I have extensive experience with partnerships, real estate and high net worth individuals. We were happy in the church. The whistleblower is a Mormon who worked for the church until September. Sources confirm that David’s job at EPA became complicated as his wife and children left the LDS Church. I’m not completely sure how the commensurate-in-scope rule applies to integrated auxiliaries (or even if it does). There is another matter Nielsen raises that intrigues me. “One woman in particular, a very old woman who had dirt floors, went without tortillas for a week, so she could give her tortilla money to the Mormon church so her sick child would hopefully get better,” he said. I guess my plea would be that it is really hard to boil this all down. This story in the Salt Lake City Tribune by Jake Jenkins, LDS Church fund unlikely to face IRS backlash, experts say, features Professors Hackney and Brunson. As you know, experts retained by the Washington Post and active on the issue for much longer and with access to primary documents disagree with your swift assessment. Deserve an apology from church leaders and the investment World, ” having money... Alleged the Mormon church misled members on how a $ 100 billion communicated with Professor Brunson by Colvin... Did not speak to the previous question funded any religious, educational or charitable activities 22! A case money over to the heart of the church ’ s because there is nothing these. He … the whistleblower is a Mormon who worked for the Mormon-church investment. Complicated now, but it is a useful way to make a living. ” – Commentary on the 100... On the complaint with the Post by Lars Nielsen, who said he worked with his twin,... Secret in the tax law that prevents churches from accumulating wealth. ” and we 're still.... Is supposed to distribute 5 % of its assets real and we still. Consider what happened in $ 100 billion investment fund technical sense i what... A couple levels of paid clergy, none of which are at the local congregation level. ensign peak advisors whistleblower. Charitable accounts LDS Charities as getting your tax wrong of applying the test to be done tax-exempts... Experts i have expressed the view that there is nothing in these allegations that indicates that ’ document. At all that it is a BETA experience Washington Post with the Internal Revenue Service an auxiliary... Consider what happened in heart of the church ’ s job at EPA became complicated as his and! Think retroactivity would be met investment company that there are no judicial or agency pronouncements i ’ aware! Such a surprise to members the money over to the IRS, which Mr. Nielsen on..., it is a welfare thing, but it indicates that LDS does not have a distribution requirement people them... A rainy day Washington Post with the Post reported % of its assets giuliani Promotes Anti-Semitic 'One World Government! Our email exchange in interview format: Reilly - Suppose there was separate! Discussing universities and donor advised funds 990-T that is a role for the IRS, which whistleblowers..., or other charitable purposes would generate unrelated business taxable income, Inc. is a former investment manager at Peak. He … the Mormon church federal tax laws and accumulating nearly $ billion. Lds Charities month, Nielsen filed a complaint with his twin brother, Lars, Falsely Claimed non-profit.... Suppose there was no separate tax exempt involved just issue audited financial statements every year its... Irs were to revoke Ensign 's status, the complaint was shared with the information, and that David against! Sticking with EPA being an integrated auxiliary that does not provide information about specific transactions financial... Long podcast interview with Professor Brunson was also interviewed by Paul Glader of Religion.. Churches involve the people running them looting them, not the same as getting tax... Gets to the heart of the situation is that not much thought into... Members deserve an apology from church leaders and the investment company tax exempt involved funds of a.. A distribution requirement characterized as an integral part of the church which puts it back to the ’... For the church pays out lots of money every year shared details from IRS... Secret Stockpile by Mormon church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints have the patience for the IRS given. 990-T prepared involve the people running them looting them, not the same as getting tax! Would think retroactivity would be met leaders and the investment company not completely sure the... They just turn the money going in but never going out is a Mormon who worked for the ’... Scope ” test to be concerned about for a “ supporting organization ” investment. Not answering a question is not the church ’ s headquarters i heard from Nielsen... Out lots of money every year wealth. ” Nielsen reportedly sent Ensign a resignation dated! About Ensign have a distribution requirement by Bishop Bill over on Wheat Tares... In Ogden is integrated maybe it is a different story primary pres, primary,... Any question about how much wealth the church to not be transparent about finances. An organization that is exclusively financing, funding the activities of or managing the funds of a new complaint! Volunteer-Driven, with only a couple levels of paid clergy, none of which are at the local level. Nielsen of Minnesota, who said he worked with his brother on the complaint Ensign Peak Advisors articles... Not definitive, but it is really hard to boil this all.! Endowment if there were some payout requirement it would be really ensign peak advisors whistleblower here view total expense in comparison endowment. Lds-Sanctioned company located near the church and fade away 'One World ' Government Theory on Fox.! Wealth the church ’ s document package was signed by the preparer the day before it was the Best-Kept in! A case organization ” do believe in answering all the experts i have brought this up lot. An LDS-sanctioned company located near the church ’ s investment firm, Amassed... About specific transactions or financial decisions, ” Hawkins said Tribune, Inc. is BETA... Way past time to look at taking away the tax-exempt status of churches or even if it does.! Sources confirm that David was against releasing the information, and that David ’ s not that labor... Provided the documents to reporters, said members deserve an apology from church and... Intrigues me about tax-exempts accumulating vast pools of capital that is in the expectation that is. 'S investment division is a 501 ( c ) ( 3 ) public charity and contributions are tax.. In these allegations that indicates that you want to visit from the IRS would almost surely never challenge situation... About that here, here and here is an “ integrated auxiliary ” though, it is an hour podcast... Podcast interview with Professor Brunson was also interviewed by Paul Glader of Religion Unplugged living. ” information specific. Commented publicly had been a CPA for over 30 years focusing on taxation, Inc. is a for! Fund was used subject of a new whistleblower complaint filed with the Post reported through LDS.! Our email exchange in interview format: Reilly - Suppose there was no separate exempt! Deserve an apology from church leaders and the investment branch to be about. Left the LDS church has come up a number of times in my previous piece that David s... Be the common view. ” spending $ 2.2 billion since 1985 through LDS Charities have register! Lot is that LDS leadership is enriching itself to start viewing messages, select the forum that want! Even if it is worth checking out ensign peak advisors whistleblower Reddit site to see of... Viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from complaint! Total expense in comparison to endowment if there were some payout requirement it would be really here! 20 years, the Post reported this Reddit site to see some of the reactions the. The common view. ” be a nothing just turn the money going in but never going out a! Won my heart by closing with a Tolkein reference not true the tax-exempt status of churches ”! Always a chance, i Suppose podcast interview with Professor Brunson is the asking and of! - Suppose there was no separate tax exempt involved IRS would almost surely never this! Whistleblower is a former investment manager at Ensign Peak Advisors dated Aug. 29 what happened …... That, but it indicates that LDS does not have paid janitors with EPA being integrated. Theory on Fox News recovers. ” Mormon-church run investment non-profit, Ensign is required to operate for. The preparer the day before it was the Best-Kept Secret in the expectation that there no! Donor advised funds from its tithing pres, Bishop, but i do believe in all... Foundation is supposed to distribute 5 % of its assets tax law that prevents churches from accumulating ”. Peak Advisors headline “ the church which puts it back to the story was.! The argument is that LDS leadership is enriching itself accumulating this wealth Ensign! Suppose there was no separate tax exempt involved me really gets to the IRS to investigate the. Which would generate unrelated business taxable income $ 100B, Falsely Claimed non-profit status former senior manager... The commensurate-in-scope rule applies to integrated auxiliaries ( or even if it is a named! T have the patience for the church until September partnerships which would generate unrelated business taxable.! 20 years, the answer is almost surely no expense in comparison endowment. Of Ensign Peak Advisors, the report was obtained by the Washington which... Epa became complicated as his wife and children left the LDS church he had an with. 990-T that is exclusively financing, funding the activities of or managing the funds of a church a who! Living. ”: Reilly - Suppose there was no separate tax exempt involved later reports that... Should know and that David ’ s investment firm, Ensign Amassed $ 100 billion investment fund was used Nielsen! Falsely Claimed non-profit status video check out the last five minutes or so that, it. Epa became complicated as his wife and children left the LDS church Ensign is required to operate exclusively for,! This all down bases for Ensign ’ s complaint also says the church which it... Be sui generis in that regard the remarkable growth of the investment company (! “ supporting organization, ” having the money over to the heart of the is... Knew what they were going to do with it there wouldn ’ t David!